Selling on BigCommerce vs. Selling Subscription Boxes - Which Is Better?

If you’re deciding between Selling On BigCommerce or Selling Subscription Boxes, you’re in good company. It’s tough for anyone to evaluate all factors without bias, but Zeyvior AI can help. Using extensive data and thorough analysis, Zeyvior AI offers clear, easy-to-understand insights with visuals and numbers to guide your choice.

Ease of Starting & Doing

Minimal or Zero Investment

Scalability

Passive Income Potential

Market Demand

Competition Level

Immediate Earnings

Long-Term Stability

Risk of Failure

Opportunity for Newcomers

Adaptability to Changes

Global Reach & Accessibility

Skills & Experience Needed

Payment & Withdrawal Process

Ease of Making Money

Overall Score

Selling on BigCommerce

Easy to set up, but requires store customization, product sourcing, and marketing.

64/100

Monthly fees apply, plus potential costs for inventory, ads, and premium features.

60/100

Highly scalable with automation and multiple sales channels.

90/100

Not fully passive—inventory management, customer service, and marketing are needed.

55/100

E-commerce demand is growing, but success depends on niche selection.

85/100

Highly competitive, especially in popular niches.

50/100

Sales take time due to product sourcing and traffic generation.

50/100

Stable if the store has a strong brand and customer base.

80/100

Risk exists due to competition and marketing costs.

55/100

Beginners can enter, but success requires effort in branding and promotion.

75/100

Flexible business model, but algorithm changes and competition can impact success.

80/100

Can sell worldwide, but shipping and taxes must be considered.

85/100

Requires knowledge of e-commerce, marketing, and product sourcing.

55/100

Supports various payment gateways, but withdrawal times vary.

90/100

Profits require consistent marketing and store optimization.

60/100

73.3/100

Selling subscription boxes

Selling subscription boxes requires initial setup, such as finding suppliers, creating a website, and managing logistics. While platforms like Cratejoy make the process easier.

60/100

Starting a subscription box business often requires upfront costs for inventory, packaging, and website setup. With zero investment, it takes significant initial effort and resources to launch effectively.

55/100

The subscription box model can grow significantly, especially if a brand attracts loyal subscribers. Growth requires substantial effort in sourcing new products and maintaining customer engagement.

70/100

While subscription boxes can generate recurring income once established, ongoing work is required to manage subscriptions, renewals, and customer relationships.

55/100

The market for subscription boxes is diverse and growing, especially in niche areas like beauty, fitness, or food.

75/100

The subscription box market is becoming increasingly crowded, and success depends on standing out. Niche offerings can be effective, but competition is high.

60/100

It can take several months to start earning significant profits. Initially, most of the income goes toward operational costs, and profits are slow to materialize.

50/100

With a loyal customer base and effective logistics, subscription boxes can offer steady income. However, the business’s success can fluctuate depending on market trends and customer retention.

65/100

There’s a moderate risk, especially if the market becomes saturated or if customer retention drops. However, with careful planning and marketing, the risk of failure can be minimized.

59/100

Newcomers can find success, but they face challenges due to the competition and the need for effective marketing. Niche products can help reduce barriers to entry.

70/100

Subscription box services are somewhat adaptable, but they can be vulnerable to changes in consumer preferences, shipping costs, and platform policies.

60/100

Subscription box services can be accessed globally, but shipping restrictions and costs may limit certain regions. Platforms help in making the service more accessible to international customers.

65/100

No advanced skills are required, but having some knowledge of logistics, marketing, and customer service is essential to succeed in the long run.

65/100

Most subscription box services offer straightforward payment processes through platforms like PayPal, and earnings can be withdrawn relatively easily.

80/100

Making money is not guaranteed and requires significant effort in marketing, customer retention, and sourcing products. Income generation is ongoing but not effortless.

55/100

62.1/100

Zeyvior AI rates Selling On BigCommerce at 75% and Selling Subscription Boxes at 70%, showing both have room for improvement. If you’re just starting out and unsure which way to go, selling on Fiverr might be a more suitable option. Looking for other possibilities? Explore more choices using the buttons below.

Selling On BigCommerce scores 64%, slightly ahead of Subscription Boxes at 60%. Both methods are fairly easy to start, but BigCommerce offers a bit more simplicity to get going quickly. Interested in the easiest path to start? Explore the full details below.

Subscription Boxes score 65%, higher than BigCommerce’s 55%, meaning they require less skill or experience. If you want a beginner-friendly method, selling subscription boxes could be a good fit. Curious about more beginner-friendly ideas? Find out more below.

Looking for More Solutions to Compare with Selling on BigCommerce?

Compare Selling On BigCommerce with Other E-commerce Stores

Looking for More Solutions to Compare with Selling Subscription Boxes?

Compare Selling Subscription Boxes with Other E-commerce Stores

BigCommerce leads with 60%, compared to Subscription Boxes at 55% for requiring minimal upfront costs. If starting with low or no investment is your goal, BigCommerce might be the better choice. Want to learn about other low-investment options? Check the links below.

Selling Subscription Boxes has a slightly lower risk of failure with 59%, compared to BigCommerce at 55%. If minimizing risk is important, Subscription Boxes offer a safer route. Looking for lower-risk methods? Discover your options by clicking below.

Selling On BigCommerce vs. Selling Subscription Boxes: A Quick Comparison

Selling On BigCommerce and Selling Subscription Boxes are two popular methods to start an online business, but they differ in several important ways.

Key Differences
Definition

Selling On BigCommerce: Running an e-commerce store on the BigCommerce platform to sell products directly to customers.
Selling Subscription Boxes: Offering curated products on a recurring subscription basis, often focused on specific niches or themes.

Ease of Getting Started

BigCommerce: Offers a user-friendly setup with many tools for launching an online store quickly.
Subscription Boxes: May require more planning to curate products and manage recurring shipments.

Investment and Skills

BigCommerce: Requires some upfront investment in website setup and marketing, with moderate skill needs.
Subscription Boxes: Often needs less technical skill but involves sourcing products and managing subscriptions.

Market Potential and Demand

BigCommerce: Provides access to a broad market with high demand for various products.
Subscription Boxes: Appeals to niche audiences and benefits from growing interest in curated experiences.

Overall Scores

Selling On BigCommerce: 73.3%
Selling Subscription Boxes: 62.1%

While Selling On BigCommerce offers a higher overall score, making it a strong choice for those seeking a flexible and scalable online store, Selling Subscription Boxes remain a compelling option for those interested in specialized, recurring revenue models. Both methods come with unique benefits and considerations, so choosing the right one depends on your goals and resources.

Looking to compare Selling On BigCommerce and Selling Subscription Boxes using up-to-date data and current trends? Zeyvior AI provides reliable insights to help you make informed choices for your next online business move. Need to compare other topics like finance, technology, or beyond? Zeyvior AI is here to assist. Give it a try and make decisions with confidence!