Selling on Etsy vs. Selling on BigCommerce– Which is Better?

Not sure whether to start with Etsy or BigCommerce? You’re not alone—choosing the right platform can be challenging. Zeyvior AI helps by analyzing large datasets across multiple factors like ease of use, costs, competition, and growth potential. The result? Clear, easy-to-read insights and scores that help you confidently explore which option may suit your goals best.

Ease of Starting & Doing

Minimal or Zero Investment

Scalability

Passive Income Potential

Market Demand

Competition Level

Immediate Earnings

Long-Term Stability

Risk of Failure

Opportunity for Newcomers

Adaptability to Changes

Global Reach & Accessibility

Skills & Experience Needed

Payment & Withdrawal Process

Ease of Making Money

Overall Score

Selling on Etsy

Creating a shop is simple, but listing products, pricing, and branding require effort.

65/100

Low listing fees, but physical products require material costs and time investment.

44/100

Selling digital products offers good scalability; physical products require production scaling.

79/100

Digital products can generate passive income, but physical items require ongoing work.

54/100

Niche and handmade products have strong demand, but trends fluctuate.

85/100

High competition in popular categories, requiring strong branding and marketing.

50/100

Takes time to gain visibility and customer trust before generating sales.

40/100

Etsy is a stable platform, but algorithm changes and competition can affect sales.

75/100

Many sellers struggle to stand out, and success depends on effective marketing.

40/100

New sellers can succeed with unique products and marketing strategies.

70/100

Etsy adapts well, but sellers must adjust to platform fees and policy updates.

65/100

Available in most countries, but shipping costs and regulations vary.

80/100

Product creation, branding, and marketing skills are helpful for success.

50/100

Reliable payouts, but processing times vary by country.

75/100

Success depends on effective marketing, competitive pricing, and niche selection.

55/100

68.1/100

Selling on BigCommerce

Easy to set up, but requires store customization, product sourcing, and marketing.

64/100

Monthly fees apply, plus potential costs for inventory, ads, and premium features.

60/100

Highly scalable with automation and multiple sales channels.

90/100

Not fully passive—inventory management, customer service, and marketing are needed.

55/100

E-commerce demand is growing, but success depends on niche selection.

85/100

Highly competitive, especially in popular niches.

50/100

Sales take time due to product sourcing and traffic generation.

50/100

Stable if the store has a strong brand and customer base.

80/100

Risk exists due to competition and marketing costs.

55/100

Beginners can enter, but success requires effort in branding and promotion.

75/100

Flexible business model, but algorithm changes and competition can impact success.

80/100

Can sell worldwide, but shipping and taxes must be considered.

85/100

Requires knowledge of e-commerce, marketing, and product sourcing.

55/100

Supports various payment gateways, but withdrawal times vary.

90/100

Profits require consistent marketing and store optimization.

60/100

73.3/100

Zeyvior AI scores Selling on Etsy at 70% and BigCommerce at 75%.
Both platforms offer potential, but neither stands out as the perfect fit for every situation. If you’re just starting out and looking for a simpler path, Fiverr might be an easier way to begin. Want to explore more options? Use the buttons below to find what suits you best.

Selling on BigCommerce scores 55%, slightly higher than Etsy’s 50%, meaning it may need a bit more know-how. Etsy is a bit more beginner-friendly. If you prefer platforms requiring minimal experience, check out more beginner options below.

BigCommerce shows a lower risk of failure at 55%, compared to Etsy’s 40%. This indicates BigCommerce might provide a steadier foundation for sellers. Looking for safer paths to start? Click below to discover alternatives with lower risk.

Looking for More Solutions to Compare with Selling on Etsy?

Compare Selling on Etsy with other eCommerce Stores

Looking for More Solutions to Compare with Selling on BigCommerce?

Compare Selling on BigCommerce with other eCommerce Stores

BigCommerce scores 50% for immediate earnings, while Etsy scores 40%. This suggests BigCommerce may offer faster revenue potential, but both require effort to generate income. Want to find faster income opportunities? Explore more options below.

Selling on Etsy and BigCommerce both score 50% for competition, indicating a balanced market presence on each platform. Neither has a clear advantage in low competition. Interested in exploring which niches perform best? Click below to learn more.

Selling on Etsy vs. Selling on BigCommerce: A Quick Comparison

Selling on Etsy and BigCommerce are two popular approaches to launching an online business, each suited for different seller needs and goals. Etsy offers a ready-made marketplace focused on handmade and unique products, while BigCommerce provides a scalable, customizable eCommerce platform for building your own branded store.

Key Differences

Platform Type

Etsy: A marketplace connecting sellers with a large, established audience looking for creative and handcrafted goods.
BigCommerce: A self-hosted platform allowing full control over your online store’s design, features, and customer experience.

Ease of Use

Etsy: Simple to set up with minimal technical skills needed, ideal for beginners or hobby sellers.
BigCommerce: Requires more setup and technical knowledge but offers powerful tools for growing businesses.

Fees and Costs

Etsy: Charges listing fees and transaction commissions on sales.
BigCommerce: Subscription-based pricing with no direct sales commissions, plus costs for hosting and add-ons.

Audience Reach

Etsy: Access to millions of buyers already browsing the platform.
BigCommerce: Seller is responsible for driving traffic through marketing and SEO.

Control and Flexibility

Etsy: Sellers operate within Etsy’s rules and marketplace environment.
BigCommerce: Sellers have full control over branding, policies, and store features.

Overall Scores

Selling on Etsy: 68.1%
Selling on BigCommerce: 73.3%

Both platforms provide valuable opportunities depending on your goals. Etsy is great for those seeking quick access to a marketplace audience, while BigCommerce suits sellers looking for more control and growth potential in their own online store.

Looking to compare Selling on Etsy and Selling on BigCommerce using up-to-date data and current trends? Zeyvior AI delivers reliable, data-driven insights to help guide your next steps in online selling.
Need comparisons on other topics—from markets to technology and beyond? Zeyvior AI is here to help. Explore smarter choices with confidence today!